Thursday, August 07, 2008

Booking Through Thursday: Other Worlds

This week's BTT topic:
Are there any particular worlds in books where you’d like to live?
Or where you certainly would NOT want to live?
What about authors? If you were a character, who would you trust to write your life?

Great subject. Volumes, obviously, could be written about it. But I'll try to keep my thoughts brief. Well, relatively brief.

Taking the last question first: If I were a character in a work of fiction (and sometimes I feel exactly like that), I'm not sure I'd trust any author with my life. Writers are notorious for their erratic behavior when it comes to the characters they create – dropping them out of the narrative with great abandon, or killing them off for fun or profit. I don't think any of them are to be trusted completely. If you wake up one morning and find you've turned into a character in a book, watch out!

And as for worlds in books I'd like to inhabit – well, I can't think of many. Here again, most writers are best at coming up with worlds I definitely would not want to live in – like Lewis Carroll's Wonderland (absolutely overflowing with thoroughly nasty types), or Tolkien's Middle Earth (too many hellish surprises and talking trees), or the constantly-at-war world of Orwell's 1984 (too much like our own).

I can really only think of a handful of fictional worlds I'd like to spend a lot of time in – although I'm not sure I'd actually want to live in any of them. One would be The Hundred Acre Wood in A.A. Milne's books about Winnie-the-Pooh and his friends. It's always sunny, and everyone is pleasant and friendly, and just about the worst thing that ever happens is Pooh not getting his fill of honey. And I'd really love to play with Piglet.

I wouldn't mind visiting the world of Jane Austen, if I could be an aristocrat – wouldn't want to have to live in the 19th Century as one of your garden variety middle-class nobodies. I have enough trouble getting the housework and the laundry done in the present day. And Barsetshire would be another interesting place to see – but I'd prefer the Barsetshire of Angela Thirkell to that of Anthony Trollope. Much more amusing, and without all the whalebone corsets.

I think all the other worlds I'd like to be able to hang out in come from the many mystery novels I've read. Of course, they're fairly dangerous worlds – but, if you can ignore all those nasty little murders that keep cropping up, they all seem like such fascinating places. St. Mary Mead, for instance, from Agatha Christie's Miss Marple books, or Hazel Holt's Taviscombe from her Mrs. Malory mysteries. And then there's Midsomer County, the setting for Caroline Graham's series of Inspector Barnaby novels. (At least some of which, I understand, is based on the actual county of Buckinghamshire. See On the Trail of Midsomer Murders.)

And then there's the Oxford of the Inspector Morse books by Colin Dexter, but Oxford is a real place so it doesn't really count. Although if the real Oxford had as many murders going on as Dexter's fictional city does, they'd be hip-deep in dead bodies most of the time.

It's interesting, I think, that all my favorite fictional worlds are in England. I guess it's just those ancient genes trying to get back home.


  1. I can see you enjoyed answering this one. I'll bet your tongue is now permanently stuck to your cheek!

    I didn't think of Winnie the Pooh, but I'd like to help Christopher find some honey for Pooh, but I'll duck when Tigger comes bouncing by.

  2. Yes, the mother country is constantly calling our names, isn't it?

  3. Oh, I think I'd love Middle Earth, but without the impending doom and constant worry about evil creatures...a nice hobbit hole in The Shire will suit me just fine.

    Better run--it's almost time for my second breakfast!

  4. Your first answer reminds me of the Thursday Next series where books are real places.

    Pooh would be a great character to be.

  5. My favorite worlds are all in England, too! I don't even think I have English genes, although I'm moving there in a couple of months, so I guess something is calling me. LOL.

    I think it's hard to say we'd definitively want to live in a book world, because there is always conflict to move the story along, and who wants that much conflict in their life?

  6. Oxford of Inspector Morse sounds good ;0)

  7. As a child I always wanted to visit The Hundred Acre Wood (I was positive that it really existed)
    Wonderland was actually one of the places I would like to visit - I love the idea of never knowing what to expect :)

  8. I think English writers describe their country so lovingly sometimes. :-)

  9. There are times where I wouldn't mind to have a more exciting life. I would never allow my current favorite author write my life (Philippa Gregory) because chances are I'd lose my head in the process. :)


Welcome and thanks for leaving me a comment. I love to hear from visitors.

Also, please note that while I appreciate the thought, I don't play the blog awards game. I think you all deserve awards! But you might think about becoming a follower of my blog -- that would really be the best award.